![]() |
Horse Forum |
|||||||
|
||||||||
|
Note: Forum logins are completely separate from your Horsetopia classifieds account or wishlist. |
||||||
![]() |
|
|
Thread Tools |
|
|
|
|
Bombproof Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Dixonville, Alberta
Posts: 8,421
|
I think that there are good trainers and there are bad trainers and then there are trainers that fall somewhere smack dab in the middle.
I know there are people that can only do so much with there horse and need help to go the extra step ie) getting on, but all the basic ground work has been done. Once those first rides have been taken the owner can continue the riding but they are missing there learning/time to teach the horse, walk/trot and only need 30 or 60 days. Yes this horse has been started but no way to being finished. I know there are trainers out there that leave major holes in there training that shouldn't be there. Such as backing up or head tossing. Then again I know if you send your horse out for only 30 days there will be holes in some training and can't expect your horse to side pass and neck rein. I have seen what a bad trainer can do to a horse and it is not pretty and I have seen what a good trainer can do with a horse and it is amazing, all in the same amount of time. I feel if you are looking for a trainer look really careful and be able to see what the trainer has been able to do, if possible be able to see the actual owner ride the horse after the training is done as that is the real test of the training.
__________________
A penny saved is a penny you can spend on your next horse. ![]() http://nightfireranch.webs.com/index.htm Last edited by Gotta Love Duns : 08-22-2007 at 02:26 PM. Reason: forgot to spell check - ended up I didn't need to, oh well. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Pasture Pet
Join Date: Jan 2005
Location: Cleveland TX
Posts: 15,773
|
Well in this area it is tough-we looked for some time when our trainer got too booked up with halter horses to do any riders.
I will say that over the years I know far more trainers that I would NOT leave my horse with than trainers that I would. That is just my opinion. The question was good vs bad..and with that criteria I had to go with more bad than good. This entirely leaves out the biggest middle group of mediocre to does OK group. This horse is not going to make a WP horse and I am not looking to make her one,even though she was bred for it. She is solid as a rock on trails and will go through anything. She was to be for pattern classes and Trail class. I know her weak spots and she is too short to have the sweepiness for HUS, or the movement they like in WP. I was not asking for him to pound a square prg in a round hole. I called the Humane Society-they said while disturbing-it is hard to prove abuse. The big weight loss? She told me horses lose weight in training-and we have no proof of what she looked like when she left. That mare was a pudge monkey when she left. So he seems to get a pass on this incident. I hope we do not run into him-it would not be pretty.
__________________
In the right light, at the right time, everything is extraordinary. Aaron Rose |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yearling Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Fort McMurray, Alberta
Posts: 887
|
I would say that in this area, there is a big difference between people who present themselves as "trainers" and people who "train horses". Even being really, really new to English/Performance riding when I started, that distinction was really clear...and I think there are more good "trainers" in this area than bad (although lots of lively debate about whose methods are good/bad/effective). There are also a whole whack of people that run boarding operations and offer to "train" your horse while it is boarded...I would say that of the ones who advertise, there are many more weak than strong of that variety.
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Greenbroke Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Kansas
Posts: 3,517
|
Training is so subjective that it's hard to say good vs bad in a general sense. I think there are too many inexperience folks training.
As for the shortage well it's a hard stinking job (with a high potiental for injury)! And you have to be a good time manager, self directed and a savvy business person as well as talented and experienced enough with the horses. That's a hard combo to find. I think that thier are plenty of talented people who could be trainers but with out the rest it will fail as a business. I will argue the shortage of good horses. A horse is a horse. It is designed to eat grass and poo. Everything over and above that is a owner's choice. It's not a horses fault if his owners pick a job for him that he was not inclined or built to do. It's not a horses fault if he has encounted ignorate people that screwed him up. A horse may not be good at his job but that is NOT his fault. That is the fault of those trying to put him in an ill suited job.
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Greenbroke Member
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: South Carolina
Posts: 3,138
|
Well...I try very hard to be one of the good ones. The main reason, I got back into training was because....I could not find one I trusted to send my horses too and had the technology. Of course becoming a full time horse mom and getting a lighted arena....helped my decision tremendously.
But as with all things, a good trainer to you is maybe not a good trainer to others. If you are looking for thirty day wonders...then I am not your trainer. If you are looking for your horse to do something he is not happy doing...I am not your trainer. If you are looking for your money's worth in wet saddle blankets (meaning I want the horse ridden 2 hours a dat until it foams, 7 days/365) ....I am not your trainer. If your are looking for a show...I am not your trainer. I only train for people who want nice riding horses and have reasonable goals. I also have a sixty day minimum. I put the horse first and that frankly means that if I don't get the job done...the horse stays on my dime. For example...we have been having record heat indexs here. We are miserable and as everyone knows Spirit is here. Her work has been light. First she a two year old...Second it is HOT! So the fact that Bonanza called and the target delivery weekend will not work, is good news to me. We will plan on a week later to make up for the times that she has gotten 15 minutes instead of a full ride due to the heat. Yes, it is my dime...but that is fair, Right? Yes, a good training experience takes a kind, thoughtful, considerate, educated, patient trainer. It also takes an owner with reasonable goals and whole bunch of common sense. I wish trainers would seperate themselves into two groups. Starters and Finishers. I am always looking for a Crash Test Dummy I also wish the owners would seperate into two groups of the I want this people and the I want it now?
__________________
![]() There is no such thing as a always or never in the horse world. Say that one time and some horse some where will prove you wrong!. Visit us at www.woodfoxfarm.com |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yearling Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Fort McMurray, Alberta
Posts: 887
|
I keep quoting "Fugly Horse"...it's been a slow day, and I've had lots of Internet time...
They say the same thing as eieio...why aren't there more "starters" in the training world? Why does every experienced trainer seem to be a show-happy specialist? I know there are trainers like eieio out there, but sometimes they seem pretty few and far between. The other thing that my trainer taught me is that you can't just send a horse out for a whole whack of uninterrupted training. You start them, let the owner and horse re-bond and equalise to each other's levels, THEN you look at finishing training, if both are ready. Sending away a brand new 2-year old for six months and getting a futurity winning barrel runner DOES happen, a LOT around here, but is it best if you're a pleasure rider looking for a nice horse to ride? Maybe run some fun barrels out back? I would contend that no...that's not the best strategy. Thoughts? ETA: this is now a "quality" thing...not good vs. bad, I think. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Halter broke
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 176
|
What is YOUR definition (I say "your" in the collective sense as each person must define this for themselves) of good? THere is "results" good and there is "methods" good, and honestly they DON'T always equate! I know a trainer that is nationally well known and wins a LOT, his clients horses win a LOT, we are talking on the national level here, not some local rinky dink show circuit. I actually worked for him for a while. Yes he gets results, the horses do perform, BUT his methods are indescribably atrociuous if you ask me! The hroses look GORGEOUS they put their head down and keep it down (or else!). His rationale is that his clients must be able to jump on the horse and win, "any dummy has to be able to ride them". And in all the time I wokred for him I only saw three clients (he has well over 25 horses in training at any given time) actually coem and ride on a regular basis. So whose fault is this, his, or the owners???? Not defending him, there is a reason I am not there now! But when the owner expects to walk up, get on the horse and have it perform seamlessly with no real effort on the riders part, or skill I might add, then who's to say he is wrong (well I do, but....) If you send a horse to this guy you'll get what you wanted if you want a horse that wins. Now there is the opposite extreme the trainer who is overly mild with the horses, and doesn't accomplish much of anything. THey are concerned only with the method and the result may take years to achieve. So who is right and who is wrong? WHo is bad and who is good, again depends on YOUR definition.
After I go and clean the durn MESS the storm caused yesterday I will coem back and then give MY definition of good, which incidentally is how I train LOL
__________________
Horses for Sale Shawnee Acres |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Yearling Member
Join Date: Oct 2006
Location: Fort McMurray, Alberta
Posts: 887
|
That kind of leads me to this next comment...that different methods are appropriate to different levels of competition (and individual horses, but that's a different point).
For example, would you ask a Little Leaguer to train the same way as an MLB player? Of course not, that would be child abuse. 7 days a week running wind sprints, doing weights, getting yelled at for being lazy...not so much appropriate for a five-year old. OK, maybe that's not level...that's age. Let's use another analogy...let's say you have a little girl who LOVES to dance (say that little girl is me, and look closely at my avatar). This little girl does not have the build to be a professional dancer. She also doesn't have the build to even be a very GOOD dancer at the local level. Are you going to push that little girl to train seven days a week with a crazy-ballet teacher who is constantly pushing? That would be pretty cruel right, set her up to fail? On the other hand, let's say you have another little girl who is fine-boned, graceful and incredibly athletic. She also loves to dance, and she has POTENTIAL. The crazy-ballet teacher gets a GLEAM in her eye watching this little girl. This little girl gets a GLEAM in her eye thinking about the Royal Ballet...maybe then, maybe then would you put her in classes 7 times a week? Would you maybe send her away to the Royal Ballet school where she'll be pushed, pushed, pushed all the way to achieving her dream? That analogy applies to horses/riders too. WHile the National Trainer's methods are atrocious to you and your goals...he's achieving his clients' goals admirably. And I doubt that National Level competitors would stand for any kind of mistreatment...most care about their animals deeply...but they also don't want to waste talent, time and money. Their horses might have what it takes to endure the rigours of training for that level...and I would go out on a limb and say that very few horses do...so you need to find a trainer who moves appropriate to the horse, but also to your LEVEL. And be honest! What level do you want to achieve? What level is possible with this particular animal? Is it more important to bond, go slowly, not push...or to compete successfully at a high level in the minimum amount of time? And neither one of those is a "bad" goal...but they are a spectrum apart when it comes to training methods. Last edited by Perrys_mama : 08-22-2007 at 05:36 PM. |
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
Greenbroke Member
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Kansas
Posts: 3,517
|
Quote:
__________________
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Coming two
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: northeast pennsylvania
Posts: 1,876
|
T-Mom, that's why it is really hard for me to trust ANYONE with my horses, we have had 1 trainer ride Gracie and we have been there for every session, and when we first moved her we went everyday, sometimes twice a day until I trusted the girl that we were boarding with, I have seen so many nightmares it's really difficult for me to trust!
I hope you baby heals physically and mentally. I swear I would want to kill him! I'm sure there are lots of good trainers out there but I think you and your horse have to be comfortable and not everyone believes the same thing and not everyone gets along. So i think as well as having a talented trainer you also have to be compatable and strive for the same outcome. My daughter is doing fime training Gracie, we may not get results overnight but what's the hurry? They have fun learning and it's a journey they love taking together!
__________________
![]() Remember to thank the horses for the happiness and joy we experience through them! It's nice to be important, but more important to be nice! |
|
|
|
|
|
||
|
Halter broke
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 176
|
Quote:
__________________
Horses for Sale Shawnee Acres Last edited by ShawneeAcres : 08-22-2007 at 06:53 PM. |
|
|
|
|